toby

Jennifer "Jay" Toby, Class of 1990
Jay was a three- sport star at Keystone, earning nine varsity letters. During her sophomore year Jay led the team to a conference championship and was named 1st team All-County and 2nd team All-Conference. In basketball, she was honorable mention, All-County. As a junior in softball, Jay was named to the first team All-Conference, All-County, All-District, and 3rd team All-State. During Jay's junior year in basketball she earned the following honors: 1st team All-Conference and All-County, selected to the All-Tournament Team at Rocky River, member of the state All-Star team for underclassmen and the Keystone Team MVP during her junior year in volleyball, named honorable mention All-Conference and awarded, "Miss Consistency." Jay's senior year was truly outstanding in all three sports. In softball she was named 1st team All-Conference, All-County, All-District, 2nd team All-State. Jay was chosen Lorain County conference MVP, team MVP and selected to various All-Star teams. In basketball she was named 1st team All-Conference, All-County, All-District, honorable mention All-State, Lorain County Conference MVP, Team MVP and selected to the All-Tournament Team at Rocky River. In volleyball she was named 2nd team All-Conference and Coaches Award.

Jay's all-around athletic accomplishments were recognized when she was awarded the Kathy Middlesetter Award, issued annually to the best female athlete at Keystone. Additionally, Jay was runner-up Female Athlete of the Year for Lorain County.

Jay continued her athletic career at Mississippi University. In softball, she finished in the top ten in the nation for RBIs and was named 1st team, All-South Region.